| The Last One at the Wedding | Jason Rekulak | - 2024 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2025 Winner (Best Standalone Thriller Novel)
|
| The Night We Lost Him | Laura Dave | - 2024 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2025 Nominee (Best Standalone Mystery Novel)
|
| All the Sinners Bleed | S.A. Cosby | - 2023 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2024 Winner (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| A Flicker in the Dark | Stacy Willingham | - 2022 Nominee (Debut Novel)
- 2022 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best First Novel)
|
| Sundial | Catriona Ward | | - 2023 Winner (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| The Children on the Hill | Jennifer McMahon | | - 2023 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| The Fervor | Alma Katsu | | - 2023 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| The Housemaid | Freida McFadden | - 2022 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2023 Winner (Best Paperback Original Novel)
|
| The Violence | Delilah S. Dawson | | - 2023 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| Things We Do in the Dark | Jennifer Hillier | - 2022 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| Bloodline | Jess Lourey | | - 2022 Winner (Best Paperback Original Novel)
|
| House of Hollow | Krystal Sutherland | - 2021 Nominee (Young Adult Fantasy)
| - 2022 Nominee (Best Young Adult Novel)
|
| Razorblade Tears | S.A. Cosby | - 2021 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2022 Winner (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| Rock Paper Scissors | Alice Feeney | - 2021 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2022 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| The Box in the Woods | Maureen Johnson | - 2021 Nominee (Young Adult Fiction)
| - 2022 Nominee (Best Young Adult Novel)
|
| The Project | Courtney Summers | - 2021 Nominee (Young Adult Fiction)
| - 2022 Winner (Best Young Adult Novel)
|
| Blacktop Wasteland | S.A. Cosby | - 2020 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2021 Winner (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| Confessions on the 7:45 | Lisa Unger | - 2020 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| When No One Is Watching | Alyssa Cole | - 2020 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Paperback Original Novel)
|
| Winter Counts | David Heska Wanbli Weiden | - 2020 Nominee (Debut Novel)
- 2020 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2021 Winner (Best First Novel)
|
| Miracle Creek | Angie Kim | - 2019 Nominee (Debut Novel)
- 2019 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2020 Winner (Best First Novel)
|
| My Lovely Wife | Samantha Downing | - 2019 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best First Novel)
|
| Recursion | Blake Crouch | - 2019 Winner (Science Fiction)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| The Chain | Adrian McKinty | - 2019 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2020 Winner (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| The Silent Patient | Alex Michaelides | - 2019 Winner (Mystery & Thriller)
- 2019 Nominee (Debut Novel)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best First Novel)
|
| Something in the Water | Catherine Steadman | - 2018 Nominee (Debut Author)
- 2018 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2019 Nominee (Best First Novel)
|
| The Cabin at the End of the World | Paul Tremblay | | - 2019 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| The Chalk Man | C.J. Tudor | - 2018 Nominee (Debut Author)
- 2018 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2019 Winner (Best First Novel)
|
| The Lost Man | Jane Harper | - 2019 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2019 Winner (Best Paperback Original Novel)
|
| The Terminal List | Jack Carr | - 2018 Nominee (Debut Author)
| - 2019 Nominee (Best First Novel)
|
| Warcross | Marie Lu | - 2017 Nominee (Young Adult Fantasy)
| - 2019 Nominee (Best Young Adult Novel)
|
| Final Girls | Riley Sager | | - 2018 Winner (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| Stillhouse Lake | Rachel Caine | - 2017 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2018 Nominee (Best Paperback Original Novel)
|
| The Breakdown | B.A. Paris | - 2017 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2018 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| The Martian | Andy Weir | - 2018 Nominee (Best of the Best)
- 2014 Winner (Science Fiction)
- 2014 Nominee (Debut Goodreads Author)
| - 2015 Nominee (Best First Novel)
|
| Before the Fall | Noah Hawley | - 2016 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2017 Winner (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| Kill Switch | Jonathan Maberry | | - 2017 Nominee (Best Paperback Original Novel)
|
| Morning Star | Pierce Brown | - 2016 Winner (Science Fiction)
| - 2017 Nominee (Best Young Adult Novel)
|
| Underground Airlines | Ben H. Winters | - 2016 Nominee (Science Fiction)
| - 2017 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| Pretty Girls | Karin Slaughter | - 2015 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2016 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| The Girl on the Train | Paula Hawkins | - 2015 Winner (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2016 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| Broken Monsters | Lauren Beukes | | - 2015 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| Natchez Burning | Greg Iles | - 2014 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2015 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| The Weight of Blood | Laura McHugh | - 2014 Nominee (Debut Goodreads Author)
- 2014 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2015 Winner (Best First Novel)
|
| Doctor Sleep | Stephen King | | - 2014 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| Never Go Back | Lee Child | - 2013 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2014 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| Touch & Go | Lisa Gardner | - 2013 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2014 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|
| Defending Jacob | William Landay | - 2012 Nominee (Goodreads Author)
- 2012 Nominee (Mystery & Thriller)
| - 2013 Nominee (Best Hardcover Novel)
|