| All the Colors of the Dark | Chris Whitaker | - 2025 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
| - 2025 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| California Bear | Duane Swierczynski | - 2025 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
| - 2025 Winner (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| The God of the Woods | Liz Moore | - 2025 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
| - 2025 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| All the Sinners Bleed | S.A. Cosby | - 2024 Nominee (Best Mystery or Crime Novel)
| - 2024 Winner (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Dark Ride | Lou Berney | - 2024 Nominee (Best Mystery or Crime Novel)
| - 2024 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Mother-Daughter Murder Night | Nina Simon | - 2024 Nominee (Best First Mystery or Crime Novel)
| - 2024 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Golden Gate | Amy Chua | - 2024 Nominee (Best First Mystery or Crime Novel)
| - 2024 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Before You Knew My Name | Jacqueline Bublitz | - 2023 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery or Crime Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Killers of a Certain Age | Deanna Raybourn | - 2023 Winner (Best Thriller)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Secret Identity | Alex Segura | - 2023 Nominee (Best Mystery or Crime Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Shutter | Ramona Emerson | - 2023 Nominee (Best Debut Mystery or Crime Novel)
| - 2023 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Arsenic and Adobo | Mia P. Manansala | - 2022 Nominee (Best Paperback Original)
| - 2022 Winner (Best First Mystery)
|
| Clark and Division | Naomi Hirahara | - 2022 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2022 Winner (Sue Feder Historical Mystery)
|
| Girl A | Abigail Dean | - 2022 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2022 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Dark Hours | Michael Connelly | - 2022 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2022 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| We Begin at the End | Chris Whitaker | - 2022 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2022 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| All the Devils Are Here | Louise Penny | - 2021 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Blind Vigil | Matt Coyle | - 2021 Nominee (Best Thriller)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Darling Rose Gold | Stephanie Wrobel | - 2021 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Murder in Old Bombay | Nev March | - 2021 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Thursday Murder Club | Richard Osman | - 2021 Nominee (Best First Novel)
| - 2021 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| American Spy | Lauren Wilkinson | - 2020 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Gone Girl | Gillian Flynn | - 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel of the Decade)
- 2013 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2013 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| The Cartel | Don Winslow | - 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
- 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel of the Decade)
- 2016 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2016 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| The Dry | Jane Harper | - 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel of the Decade)
- 2018 Winner (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2018 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Lost Man | Jane Harper | - 2020 Winner (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2019 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Your House Will Pay | Steph Cha | - 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Dodging and Burning | John Copenhaver | - 2019 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2019 Winner (Best First Mystery)
|
| My Sister, the Serial Killer | Oyinkan Braithwaite | - 2019 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2019 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Chalk Man | C.J. Tudor | - 2019 Winner (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2019 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| A Rising Man | Abir Mukherjee | - 2018 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2018 Nominee (Sue Feder Historical Mystery)
|
| Hollywood Homicide | Kellye Garrett | - 2018 Nominee (Best Paperback Original Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2018 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Magpie Murders | Anthony Horowitz | - 2018 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2018 Winner (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| She Rides Shotgun | Jordan Harper | - 2018 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2018 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Force | Don Winslow | - 2018 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2018 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| The Lost Ones | Sheena Kamal | - 2018 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2018 Winner (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Marsh King's Daughter | Karen Dionne | - 2018 Winner (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2018 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| The Old Man | Thomas Perry | - 2018 Nominee (Best Thriller)
| - 2018 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Dodgers | Bill Beverly | - 2017 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2017 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| IQ | Joe Ide | - 2017 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2017 Winner (Best First Mystery)
|
| Under the Harrow | Flynn Berry | - 2017 Nominee (Best Paperback Original Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2017 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Wilde Lake | Laura Lippman | - 2017 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2017 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Life or Death | Michael Robotham | - 2016 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2016 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Past Crimes | Glen Erik Hamilton | - 2016 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2016 Winner (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Killing Kind | Chris Holm | - 2016 Nominee (Best Thriller)
| - 2016 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Unquiet Dead | Ausma Zehanat Khan | - 2016 Winner (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2016 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| An Officer and a Spy | Robert Harris | - 2015 Nominee (Best Thriller)
| - 2015 Nominee (Sue Feder Historical Mystery)
|
| Dear Daughter | Elizabeth Little | - 2015 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2015 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Present Darkness | Malla Nunn | - 2015 Nominee (Best Paperback Original Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2015 Nominee (Sue Feder Historical Mystery)
|
| The Black Hour | Lori Rader-Day | - 2015 Nominee (Best Paperback Original Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2015 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Killer Next Door | Alex Marwood | - 2015 Nominee (Best Paperback Original Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2015 Winner (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Cover of Snow | Jenny Milchman | - 2014 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2014 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Dead Lions | Mick Herron | - 2014 Nominee (Best Thriller)
| - 2014 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Norwegian by Night | Derek Miller | - 2014 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2014 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Rage Against the Dying | Becky Masterman | - 2014 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2014 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Ratlines | Stuart Neville | - 2014 Nominee (Best Thriller)
| - 2014 Nominee (Sue Feder Historical Mystery)
|
| Sandrine's Case | Thomas H. Cook | - 2014 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2014 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Standing in Another Man's Grave | Ian Rankin | - 2014 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2014 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Mr. Churchill's Secretary | Susan Elia MacNeal | - 2013 Winner (Best Paperback Original Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2013 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Before I Go To Sleep | S.J. Watson | - 2012 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2012 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Learning to Swim | Sara J. Henry | - 2012 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2012 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Informationist | Taylor Stevens | - 2012 Winner (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2012 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Turn of Mind | Alice LaPlante | - 2012 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2012 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Bury Your Dead | Louise Penny | - 2011 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2011 Winner (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Rogue Island | Bruce DeSilva | - 2011 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2011 Winner (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Poacher's Son | Paul Doiron | - 2011 Winner (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2011 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Thirteen Hours | Deon Meyer | - 2011 Winner (Best Thriller)
| - 2011 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| A Bad Day for Sorry | Sophie Littlefield | - 2010 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2010 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| A Trace of Smoke | Rebecca Cantrell | - 2010 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2010 Winner (Sue Feder Historical Mystery)
|
| Bury Me Deep | Megan Abbott | - 2010 Nominee (Best Paperback Original Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2010 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Running from the Devil | Jamie Freveletti | - 2010 Winner (Best Thriller)
| - 2010 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Ghosts of Belfast | Stuart Neville | - 2010 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2010 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Lincoln Lawyer | Michael Connelly | - 2010 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel of the Decade)
| - 2006 Winner (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| The Shanghai Moon | S.J. Rozan | - 2010 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2010 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| A Carrion Death | Michael Stanley | - 2009 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2009 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Cruelest Month | Louise Penny | - 2009 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2009 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Trigger City | Sean Chercover | - 2009 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2009 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| Soul Patch | Reed Farrel Coleman | - 2008 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2008 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| The Collaborator of Bethlehem | Matt Beynon Rees | - 2008 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2008 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Spellman Files | Lisa Lutz | - 2008 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2008 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| The Unquiet | John Connolly | - 2008 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2008 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| A Field of Darkness | Cornelia Read | - 2007 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2007 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| King of Lies | John Hart | - 2007 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2007 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Mr. Clarinet | Nick Stone | - 2007 Nominee (Best British Crime Novel)
| - 2007 Winner (Best First Mystery)
|
| Oh Danny Boy | Rhys Bowen | - 2007 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2007 Winner (Sue Feder Historical Mystery)
|
| Baby Game | Randall Hicks | - 2006 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2006 Nominee (Best First Mystery)
|
| Immoral | Brian Freeman | - 2006 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2006 Winner (Best First Mystery)
|
| Night's Child | Maureen Jennings | - 2006 Nominee (Best Paperback Original Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2006 Nominee (Sue Feder Historical Mystery)
|
| The James Deans | Reed Farrel Coleman | - 2006 Winner (Best Paperback Original Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2006 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|
| The Power of the Dog | Don Winslow | - 2006 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2006 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
|