| The God of the Woods | Liz Moore | - 2025 Nominee (Best Mystery Novel)
| - 2024 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| The Waiting | Michael Connelly | - 2025 Winner (Best Mystery Novel)
| - 2024 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| All the Sinners Bleed | S.A. Cosby | - 2024 Nominee (Best Mystery or Crime Novel)
| - 2023 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Dark Ride | Lou Berney | - 2024 Nominee (Best Mystery or Crime Novel)
| - 2023 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Everybody Knows | Jordan Harper | - 2024 Nominee (Best Mystery or Crime Novel)
| - 2023 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Secret Identity | Alex Segura | - 2023 Nominee (Best Mystery or Crime Novel)
| - 2022 Winner (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Razorblade Tears | S.A. Cosby | - 2022 Winner (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2021 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| The Dark Hours | Michael Connelly | - 2022 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2021 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| And Now She's Gone | Rachel Howzell Hall | - 2021 Nominee (Best Novel)
| - 2020 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Blacktop Wasteland | S.A. Cosby | | - 2020 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| November Road | Lou Berney | - 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel of the Decade)
- 2019 Winner (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2018 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| The Cartel | Don Winslow | - 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
- 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel of the Decade)
- 2016 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2015 Winner (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| The Lost Man | Jane Harper | - 2020 Winner (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2019 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Your House Will Pay | Steph Cha | - 2020 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2019 Winner (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| My Sister, the Serial Killer | Oyinkan Braithwaite | - 2019 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2018 Winner (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| My Absolute Darling | Gabriel Tallent | - 2018 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2017 Finalist (Art Seidenbaum Award for First Fiction)
|
| The Late Show | Michael Connelly | - 2018 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2017 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Dodgers | Bill Beverly | - 2017 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2016 Winner (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Bull Mountain | Brian Panowich | - 2016 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2015 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| The Long and Faraway Gone | Lou Berney | - 2016 Winner (Best Paperback Original Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2015 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| The Rage | Gene Kerrigan | - 2014 Nominee (Best Paperback Original Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2013 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Crooked Letter, Crooked Letter | Tom Franklin | - 2011 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2010 Winner (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Started Early, Took My Dog | Kate Atkinson | - 2011 Nominee (Best British Crime Novel)
| - 2011 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Black Water Rising | Attica Locke | - 2010 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2009 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Bury Me Deep | Megan Abbott | - 2010 Nominee (Best Paperback Original Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2009 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| The Ghosts of Belfast | Stuart Neville | - 2010 Nominee (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2009 Winner (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| The Hidden Man | David Ellis | - 2010 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2009 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Child 44 | Tom Rob Smith | - 2009 Winner (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2008 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| Envy the Night | Michael Koryta | - 2009 Nominee (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2008 Winner (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| The Finder | Colin Harrison | - 2009 Nominee (Best Thriller)
| - 2008 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| In the Woods | Tana French | - 2008 Winner (Best First Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2007 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|
| The Night Gardener | George Pelecanos | - 2007 Winner (Best Mystery/Crime Novel)
| - 2006 Finalist (Mystery/Thriller)
|