| 2023 | The Invisible Hour | Goodreads Choice Awards source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Nominee · Fiction | |
| 2021 | Magic Lessons | Mythopoeic Fantasy Awards source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Finalist · Adult Literature | |
| 2021 | The Book of Magic | Goodreads Choice Awards source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Nominee · Fantasy | |
| 2020 | The World That We Knew | Dayton Literary Peace Prize source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Winner · Fiction | |
| 2020 | The World That We Knew | Andrew Carnegie Medals for Excellence source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Longlist · Fiction | |
| 2020 | Magic Lessons | Goodreads Choice Awards source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Nominee · Historical Fiction | |
| 2019 | The World That We Knew: A Novel | National Jewish Book Awards source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Winner · Book Club Award | |
| 2019 | The World That We Knew | Chicago Public Library Best of the Best source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Selection · Best Books | |
| 2018 | The Rules of Magic | Mythopoeic Fantasy Awards source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Finalist · Adult Literature | |
| 2018 | Faithful | Dublin Literary Award source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Longlist · Fiction | |
| 2017 | The Rules of Magic | Reese's Book Club source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Selection · Book Club Selection | |
| 2017 | The Rules Of Magic | NPR Books We Love source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Selection · Books We Love | |
| 2017 | The Rules of Magic | Barnes & Noble Best Books of the Year source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Selection · Fiction | |
| 2016 | Faithful | The Globe and Mail Globe 100 source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Selection · Fiction | |
| 2015 | The Marriage of Opposites | Goodreads Choice Awards source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Nominee · Historical Fiction | |
| 2015 | Nightbird | Chicago Public Library Best of the Best source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Selection · Best Fiction for Older Readers | |
| 2015 | The Marriage Of Opposites | NPR Books We Love source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Selection · Books We Love | |
| 2015 | The Marriage of Opposites | Washington Post Best Books of the Year source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Selection · Notable Fiction | |
| 2014 | The Museum of Extraordinary Things | Goodreads Choice Awards source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Nominee · Historical Fiction | |
| 2013 | The Dovekeepers | Dublin Literary Award source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Longlist · Fiction | |
| 2011 | The Dovekeepers | Goodreads Choice Awards source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Nominee · Historical Fiction | |
| 2011 | The Dovekeepers | Amazon Editors' Best Books of the Year source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Selection · Top 100 | |
| 2009 | The Story Sisters | Booklist Editors' Choice source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Selection · Adult Books for Young Adults: Fiction | |
| 2007 | Incantation | Sydney Taylor Book Award source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Honor · Young Adult | |
| 2006 | Incantation | Publishers Weekly Best Books source ↗ (opens in a new tab) | Selection · Children's Fiction | |